Disney puts dark spin on Christmas classic

Review
Monday, December 7th, 2009
ShareThis

Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol” is perhaps the most widely known Christmas story of all time. It’s been done and redone so many times I find myself suffering from “bah-humbug” fatigue before Christmas even arrives.

Even having seen most, if not all, versions of “A Christmas Carol,” I still was not prepared for what awaited me.

When Disney brought out their version of A Christmas Carol they sold it as a very kid-friendly, cool, 3D version written and produced by “Polar Express” director Robert Zemeckis.

I can honestly say they lied. What starts out a classic soon turns gritty and scary. I’m not a fan of scary movies anyway, but there were children in the audience who had to be removed because they were so frightened. This film earned its PG rating and a little extra.

Honestly this is probably the most realistic rendition of the film and runs more along the lines of what Dickens intended. It’s gritty, cold and even the happy ending is lackluster.

It will leave you wondering if Christmas truly was ever a happy time or if you were blinded by the Christmas lights and presents.

Zemeckis revs up the fear factor blatantly telling the audience those who do not give to others will be doomed to purgatory.

As for the 3D, save your money. Other than a few snow flurries and reaching hands, the 3D affects are not maximized to their full potential. You’ll be more amazed at how realistic the hairs on Ebenezer Scrooge’s nose looks.

If you must go and see this new version, spare your children the nightmares and leave the baby sitter enough money to rent Disney Pixar’s UP.

Two out of four stars.